Key Takeaways
- Both platforms represent the two distinct models within voiceover marketplaces. Voice Crafters combines a curated agency + marketplace model, while Voice123 operates as a large, open “pay-to-play” marketplace.
- Voice Crafters ensures all its talent is pre-vetted, whereas Voice123 allows anyone to join, making quality more variable.
- On the Voice123 platform, clients will find hundreds of thousands of voice actors. On the other hand, Voice Crafters, which started as a boutique agency, provides a smaller, more focused, quality-led talent pool.
- Voice Crafters focuses on human-only voice work, while Voice123 includes AI voices and voice cloning options.
Over the past couple of months, we’ve been running a series of articles comparing Voice Crafters with other well-known voiceover marketplaces.
These include sector heavyweights such as Voquent, Eleven Labs, and Fiverr.
In this piece, we’re keeping the bar high by examining the similarities and differences between Voice Crafters and the company widely regarded as the first online marketplace for voice actors – Voice123.
As with our earlier articles, we’ll be using the same set of criteria to assess both platforms:
- Vetting and Voice Talent Quality
- Service Model and Managed Support
- Diversity and Localization Depth
- Pricing and Transparency
- Technology and AI Stance
- Search Functionality and User Experience (UX)
So, let’s get to it!
Voice Crafters vs. Voice123: A Short History of Each Company
ID: Voice Crafters
Voice Crafters is an online voiceover marketplace and boutique agency that’s been active for a little under two decades.
It was founded by Mony Raanan as a curated agency focusing on verified, professional voice talent for businesses.
However, over the years, it has expanded into an online platform where clients can also post projects, get auditions, and handle the casting process themselves, as well as receive done-for-you support if preferred.
All voice actors on the site are still fully vetted so that clients can be sure they’re working with experienced professionals, no matter who they choose.
Today, Voice Crafters operates globally, providing studio-quality voiceovers in over 80 languages.
ID: Voice123
Voice123 was launched in 2003 as the world’s first digital marketplace connecting clients directly with voice actors.
It was founded by Tania Zapata and Alex Torrenegra, who later also went on to found Bunny Studio.
Over the last 23 years, it has built a large global user base who “pay to play” and claims to have completed one million voiceover projects via the platform.
During that time, the platform introduced a number of changes, including its somewhat controversial SmartCast casting algorithm, which effectively controlled the number of invitations sent to voice actors but which has since been replaced by a less restrictive matching algorithm tool.
In recent years, Voice123 has also embraced AI voices and text-to-speech technology.
Voice Crafters & Voice123: Service Model
|
FEATURE
|
VOICE CRAFTERS
|
VOICE123 |
|
Service Model |
Hybrid (mix of marketplace + bespoke project management & production services) |
Online marketplace with optional project management through Voice123 Enterprise service |
|
Vetting |
Vetted professionals only |
No pre-screening. Talent of all levels can set up a profile through the “pay-to-play” structure |
|
Roster Style |
Boutique / Curated |
Large open marketplace with thousands of voice actors worldwide |
|
Speciality |
Multilingual Commercial & Corporate (High-end) |
Large-scale casting marketplace across many voiceover categories, including AI voices |
|
Project Management |
Clients can opt for full agency support or post projects/casting notices & manage projects themselves |
Primarily self-service. Clients post projects, receive auditions, select talent, and manage the project directly. “Enterprise” option for full production or casting director services |
|
AI Policy |
Strictly Human voices. Does not support TTS/AI voice synthesis for promotional use unless talent grants permission and receives ongoing usage payment |
At specific tier levels, AI/voice cloning is permitted. Projects must include talent consent and specific usage agreements |
|
Payment |
Secure payment system. Funds are held until the project is approved. Payment via Stripe, PayPal, or bank transfer.
Platform fees are typically 10% from client and 10% from talent. No subscription fee for voice actors |
Voice actors pay subscription/membership fees for access to auditions and increased visibility. There is one free tier level, but visibility in minimal.
Clients pay talent through the platform, with an option to use platform’s secure payment service |
| Contract Type |
Project-based |
Project-based |
What are Voice Crafters’ & Voice123’s Talent Vetting Processes?
As voiceover marketplaces go, one of the biggest differences between these two is their vetting process.
Voice Crafters
Voice Crafters employs a relatively strict screening process. Voice actors have to submit professional demos and raw audio recordings from their home studios for technical review.
Raanan and the team then evaluate the actor’s performance and recording quality, ensuring that the audio meets their high broadcast-ready specifications.
This vetting ensures that clients can be confident of only working with experienced talent who can deliver broadcast-quality work.
Voice123
Voice 123 uses a “pay-to-play” structure, which means that talent isn’t vetted but rather joins the site by subscribing and then receives audition invitations based on their chosen subscription plan’s matching criteria.
For example, voice actors starting out or working part-time can choose from three different tiered annual plans, the first being a free plan.
However, the free tier only gives subscribers access to 1% of matching projects, while the other two annual plans, which are $49 and $199, give access to 9% and 20%, respectively.
Pro Plans and Elite Plans are best for professional voiceover artists, and prices range from $495 per year to the Elite plan, which costs a yearly payout of $4,950.
Mind you, this latter tier gives actors access to 95% of matching projects and ensures they’re featured on the first page of search results.
Services Included & Pricing Structure
Voice Crafters
Voice Crafters’ goal is to provide clients with exceptional voice talent, whether they’re casting their own projects or relying on Voice Crafters to manage everything for them.
Projects can range from simple voice recordings to full multilingual production campaigns, with the talent on the platform having experience in everything from corporate videos and training content to TV and radio ads and animated movies.
Over the years, Voice Crafters, as a voiceover business, has expanded to include end-to-end support, with services such as:
Pricing is on a project basis and can vary depending on elements such as project complexity and length, and usage rights. There are no fixed public pricing tiers.
Voice123
Voice123 set out to provide a wide array of voice talent for all types of projects and budgets.
It has succeeded in that it now boasts a global roster of over 500,000 members, with clients able to choose from self-service to full-production support.
For customers in a hurry, Voice123 Studio offers a fast turnaround option.
Clients complete a short project brief, and the platform matches the job with a suitable voice actor from its curated pool. A completed recording is then delivered quickly, with up to three takes included.
In terms of pricing, talent must select one of the platform’s tiered annual plans that range from $495 to $4,950, with higher tiers offering better visibility and better chances of early audition invitations.
For clients, there’s flexibility to negotiate project fees directly with talent, with rates varying widely based on the voice actor’s experience as well as the project scope and usage.
How do These Two Voiceover Marketplaces Rate on Search Functionality and User Experience?
Voice Crafters
The Voice Crafters site is easy to use, with clients able to quickly filter voice actors by language, styles, gender, age, and categories.
This makes it pretty simple to narrow down suitable talent without sorting through an overwhelming number of profiles.
Clients can post a project or find additional services such as post-production or video translation in just one or two clicks, making the platform super-straightforward to navigate.
As all the platform’s talent pool is pre-screened, the search process tends to be more focused, with clients also able to use the search function to quickly pull up talent they’ve worked with before.
Voice123
As Voice123 provides a much larger database, it relies heavily on keyword-driven search and filtering tools.
Clients can search for voices using descriptive keywords before narrowing down results by language, accent, gender, and other criteria.
This enables them to browse audio samples directly on talent profiles.
As clients and talent deal directly with one another, the platform integrates messaging, auditions, and booking features into the same interface.
The search process can be a tad more time-consuming, but this is to be expected with a platform of this scale.
How are Voice Crafters and Voice123 Rated as Voiceover Marketplaces by Both Clients and Talent?
Voice Crafters
Voice Crafters reviewers tend to offer positive feedback for the high caliber of talent, quick turnarounds, but most of all for the human attention that Raanan and the team give to every project to ensure.
As one client writes:
The job is done well or not at all… Voice Crafters certainly know how to do it well, and now they’ve raised the bar high for what we will expect from a service like this in the future!
Reviews from voice actors note appreciation for the clear communication and the ethical approach to voiceover rates.
Voice123
Online reviews for Voice123 are a mixed bag, particularly when left by voice actors.
Many praise the great support and audition opportunities, citing Voice123 as the place where they’ve secured their best and longest-running repeat clients.
The fact that the talent can deal directly with clients gets a thumbs up too, with one happy voice actor review stating it was a “wonderful bridge to clients, without gatekeeping like other platforms.”
However, others claim to have difficulties getting auditions or booking work even with a paid membership, while also noting that auditions are sent at unworkable times.
Many of the more negative feedback suggests the problem is with Voice123’s current model, claiming it doesn’t deliver the volume or quality of opportunities it once did.
Client reviews are not as easy to find, though those that are available online commend the ease of hiring and the strong support they receive from Voice123 for finding the talent they need.
Final Thoughts
Choosing between Voice Crafters and Voice123 is really a choice between fully vetted, experienced voiceover talent or a huge pool of voice actors with experience ranging from new kid on the block to veteran voice actor.
If you want to know you’re getting top-dollar talent for your…well, dollars, the flexibility to choose between self-service hiring and managed production, and a platform that supports projects in more than 80 languages, then Voice Crafters is a no-brainer.
If, on the other hand, you want flexibility in your budget, a voiceover marketplace with extensive global reach, and fast casting through multiple, immediate auditions, then Voice123 ticks all those boxes.
0 Comments